49051

How Pride Can Unknowingly Be Disguised as Humility

Years ago, before the Church instituted the three-hour block schedule for our Sunday meetings, we used to go to the chapel for meetings three times every Sunday—once in the morning for priesthood meeting, a second time for Sunday School opening exercises and classes, and finally a third time for a ninety-minute sacrament meeting. When I was a very young man, our ward’s Sunday School superintendent, Brother Marchant, came to our class one Sunday to ask for volunteers who would be willing to give the prayer, the 2½-minute talks, and the sacrament gem (a verse of scripture shared before the sacrament was passed) in the following week’s Sunday School opening exercises. My strategy was to quickly volunteer to say either the prayer or the sacrament gem. I was motivated by the desire to avoid having to give a talk at all costs! Unfortunately for me, I wasn’t the only person in the class with that strategy, and I missed out on my first choice, the prayer. I was quick enough, however, to score the sacrament gem assignment. Given the other alternative, I felt lucky.

That week I memorized my scripture, and I arrived early the following Sunday to sit on the stand. As the meeting got underway, however, I realized that I didn’t know for sure at what point in the meeting I was to stand up and recite my scripture. I asked the young man who had been assigned the talk if he knew, but he was as unsure as I was. I began to search my memory in panic. My memories of all the Sundays I had witnessed immediately cured into a single mass of impenetrable concrete. I had no idea when my turn was.

So I guessed.

Unfortunately, I guessed wrong. I had made it through nearly all of my scripture when I felt Brother Marchant’s huge hand on my shoulder. Stretching himself to his full height just to my left, he said to the congregation, “I’d like to thank Jimmy for his outstanding preparation and enthusiasm.” Then he turned to me and whispered, “You don’t go until after the talks.”

I was mortified. I caught a glance of my mother as I turned to take my seat, and I could tell that she was embarrassed for me as well, which made me feel even lower.

I tried to calm myself when I sat back down. Although my cheeks and ears burned with embarrassment, I was slowly gathering my composure when a new thought sent me tumbling into panic once more. Brother Marchant said I was to give my scripture after the talks, but he didn’t say WHEN after them! Now I was really worried. I tried to get Brother Marchant’s attention without being too obvious, but he didn’t notice me. I didn’t know what to do.

So I guessed again.

Right after the last talk, I rose again and started to recite my scripture. I knew something was wrong when I glanced down at our organist, Sister Hubbert, whose pained look signaled that I would soon be feeling Brother Marchant’s hand again.

This time he just tugged on my pocket. “I will nod at you when you are to go,” he whispered. I staggered back to my seat like a drunkard. I’m not being literary here. I really did fake a drunkard’s walk, which of course made me feel even more stupid when the ridiculousness of that act hit me. I made sure that I didn’t glance over at my mother.

I am probably the only person in the history of the Church who has offered the sacrament gem three times in a single meeting. At that moment, and at my age, the thought crushed me. I ran from the building the moment the meeting ended. I exited from the side door of the chapel and escaped into the ignorant and nonjudgmental outdoors. I sprinted home. I wouldn’t be going to class, and there was no way I was going back to sacrament meeting. In fact, I remember vowing that I would never go to church again.

Since I was so down in that moment, you might think that I darted from the church a humble soul. That wouldn’t be the truth, however. Feeling humiliated is a world apart from feeling humble. Humiliation is what one feels when one’s pride has been injured. Whenever we are feeling down about feeling down, we have become consumed with ourselves every bit as much as those who are feeling up about feeling up.

When we are burdened by feelings of inadequacy, we are failing to understand two freeing truths. The first is that we are not yet grasping that, with respect to the law, every person is both equally separated from God and equally “rescuable” by him. Downtrodden pride doesn’t believe that. When suffering from this kind of pride, we believe, instead, that we are guiltier or more broken than others—in some cases, even irretrievably so. We know that we’ve been commanded to love, for example, but we are keenly and painfully aware of how often our hearts are raging, even when we are outwardly doing good. And we feel terrible about this. We feel guilty, but we are not humble, despite appearances. We are mad at ourselves that we are not as good as we want to be—as we believe we need to be.

The second great truth we are missing is that we do not yet understand and have faith in the Lord’s mission to redeem us. Although we might understand the point in our minds, our hearts do not yet believe that this redemption does not depend on our perfection. It is well that we are taking the Lord’s commandments seriously, but we are at the same time taking ourselves too seriously and him not seriously enough. We are in the middle of a misunderstanding that Paul was trying to rectify in his readers when he explained that we are justified not by our deeds but by faith—that is, by Christ.136

When I have been burdened with this version of pride, I have observed in myself one of two outward styles. The first style is a kind of hyperactive righteousness—an exhausting obsession with doing outwardly good things that loves itself doing the good things more than it loves those good things or the people for whom they are done. When we are living this way, every moment is a moment to prove ourselves, and we are consumed with how others are regarding us. The story of Martha in the tenth chapter of Luke can be read as an example of this. She had received the Master into her house in Bethany. While her sister, Mary, “sat at Jesus’ feet, and heard his word,” the scripture says that “Martha was cumbered about much serving, and came to him, and said, Lord, dost thou not care that my sister hath left me to serve alone? bid her therefore that she help me. And Jesus answered and said unto her, Martha, Martha, thou art careful and troubled about many things: But one thing is needful: and Mary hath chosen that good part, which shall not be taken away from her.”137

On occasion, I have heard this story interpreted in ways that are attempts to ennoble Martha and absolve her of any wrongdoing—perhaps as a way to preserve the feelings of any of us who have ever played the part of Martha in our own lives. (And who hasn’t?) But I think we risk missing the point when we do this, and, in fact, can become “cumbered about” in our interpretations. It is okay to have a problem. It is okay for Martha to have a problem. It is okay for Mary to have a problem. The healer of those problems was sitting in their home. But on this occasion, Martha, just as I know I frequently am, was too cumbered about and troubled about many things—her own things, such as the sufficiency of her meal, perhaps the state of her house, and so on—to receive the peace that was sitting right before her. “But didn’t people need to eat?” one might object in defense. To which I would only observe that Jesus didn’t rebuke Martha for her work but for her feelings. At least on the surface, the story may well be an example of an outwardly frantic style of downtrodden up-ness—the need always to look good or to be recognized as thoughtful. It is a personal need, a need necessitated by pride. When we suffer from this kind of pride, we don’t just serve but “are cumbered about much serving,” and are “careful and troubled about many things.”138

The second style, by contrast, is a kind of giving up and shutting down. It is what I was doing when I vowed never to go to church again. Jesus spoke of this in his parable of the talents.139 You know the story. A man gathered his servants to him before he left on a long trip. He divided his property between them—to one servant five talents (a very large sum of money), to a second two talents, and to the third one talent. The servant who had received five talents used them to produce an additional five talents for a total of ten. The second servant did the same, doubling his two talents for a total of four. The third servant, however, thinking his lord a judgmental and “hard man,”140 and perhaps feeling like he was not as favored as the other servants, was afraid and hid his lone talent in the earth.

Upon their lord’s return, they were asked for an accounting. To the first two servants, who had doubled their property, the lord said, “Well done, thou good and faithful servant: thou hast been faithful over a few things, I will make thee ruler over many things: enter thou into the joy of thy lord.”141 However, upon hearing the report from the servant who had hid his talent, he said: “Thou wicked and slothful servant, thou . . . oughtest . . . to have put my money to the exchangers, and then at my coming I should have received mine own with [interest]. Take therefore the talent from him, and give it unto him which hath ten talents. For unto every one that hath shall be given, and he shall have abundance: but from him that hath not shall be taken away even that which he hath.”142

This parable reveals, among other things, that any kind of self-concern, including a self-concern that leads one to shut down and give up (as, for example, a fear to fail) is itself a kind of pride. Feeling depressed that I am worse than others is as much an act of pride as feeling myself better. Both are acts of self-concern—with oneself, rather than Christ, at the center.

The gospel, by its very nature, is designed to strip us of pride—of either the “I am better” or “I am worse” variety. And what is to take its place? The simple realization that “I am in need of Him.” The gospel is designed to rescue us from our concern for self by making us equally in need of the same merciful Other—One who loves us (and our neighbors) infinitely, no matter what we (and our neighbors) might have done.

Lead image from Getty Images

^135. See 2 Nephi 28:21.

^136. See Romans 3:23–31.

^137. See Luke 10:38–42.

^138. See Luke 10:40–41.

^139. See Matthew 25:14–30.

^140. See Matthew 25:24.

^141. Matthew 25:21, 23.

^142. Matthew 25:26–29.


As incredible as it may sound, much of the sadness and frustration we feel in mortality is actually created by our well-meaning efforts to find happiness. Relief from this predicament can be found through a divine gospel paradox that rescues us from failed roads and puts us on the surprising path to happiness.

Through engaging stories and fresh, invigorating gospel insights, James Ferrell has written a book that challenges our unquestioned and perhaps mistaken assumptions about many of life's fundamental concerns. For example, what if happiness depends less on forgiving ourselves than on giving up that quest? What if repentance is even sweeter than forgiveness? What if neither happiness nor heaven can be reached by climbing?

Falling to Heaven is an account of a gospel that's specifically designed to change our minds and transform our hearts. It is an account of the truths of Christ that really do set us free.

Comments and feedback can be sent to feedback@ldsliving.com