{LDSL Blog} Mormon Republicans vs. Mormon Democrats
Kate Ensign-Lewis - October 04, 2012
There may be more of us Mormons on one side of the spectrum, but that doesn't mean there's only one right way to vote. In fact, both parties emphasize gospel principles; if we only reached across the aisle more often, we might realize that.
Harry Reid (Mormonism’s most famous Democrat) recently asserted that Mitt Romney (our most famous Republican) is not the face of Mormonism. When we ran the article last Tuesday, many of our readers responded. And as usually happens in comments that imply taking a side, things got a little heated.
Too often we vilify the “other” political party—and too often conservative Mormons (and let’s face it—that’s most of us) vilify Democrats. (I know it goes the other way, too.) Sometimes we even question each other’s testimonies because of our political beliefs. This is silly and, quite simply, un-Christlike—there is a true gospel, but there is no “one true” political party. In fact, I think both parties espouse important gospel truths—which is why we have Mormons on both sides of most debates.
I have a theory of why we Mormons choose the political parties we do. The theory is based solely on gospel principles and ideals—not on agendas or special interests. Basically, it comes down to AGENCY and LOVE.
Some Mormons fall on the right of the spectrum (“conservative,” “Republican,” or even “Libertarian” in the U.S.). They fall here because the party emphasizes AGENCY—freedom for the people to choose how they live and where they put their money and resources, without being compelled. They believe the government should be small, and its biggest responsibility is to ensure people maintain their power of choice.
Other Mormons fall on the left of the spectrum (“liberal” or “Democrat” in the U.S.). They fall here because the party emphasizes LOVE, in the form of helping the poor or disadvantaged and generally being more accepting of different minorities. They believe the government’s biggest responsibility is to give people opportunities for success and ensure a better life for all citizens, and they emphasize finding new ways to do so through programs and projects.
Both of these principles are fundamental in the gospel, and that's not to say that people who choose one party don't also firmly believe in the other party's guiding principle. They simply have different beliefs about what the government's most important responsibilities are and which principles are better emphasized.
The theory is simplistic, yes, but from the conversations I’ve had with Mormons on both sides, it fits pretty well on an idealistic level. I know some people choose political parties because of a few very specific platforms, but I would hope that's not true for Mormons. I honestly think that most of us Mormons think of these things in a gospel sense—which party is truest to the foundations of how we live Christ’s gospel. We ran a great article last year that touches on this very idea.
In short, we choose our political parties BECAUSE of our LDS beliefs, not in spite of them.
So, this leaves us with the final question: Does the theory work for you? Why do you fall on the political spectrum where you do? How is it informed by your beliefs?
And, although I can hope it’s unnecessary, it's better safe than sorry to request: Please, if you refer to other commenters or the "other" political party, remember to be civil. There’s a saying I once heard that fits in this situation and goes something like this: you don’t have truth, and I don’t have truth—but together, we can come to a greater truth. There are good people across the political spectrum, and we all have something to learn from reaching across the aisle—whether that be in church or in politics.
- -
Kate Ensign-Lewis is an online editor with LDS Living, a wife, and a mother to an adorable one-year-old. She enjoys talking about politics, although she still hasn’t been able to figure out which party fits her best—which is why she is a registered Independent.
© LDS Living, 2012.
Home
Advertise
About Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Subscribe
©2013 LDS Living, A Division of Deseret Book Company.
















kathycopper said...
08:09 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
irish said...
09:20 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
robokenn said...
09:35 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
grams said...
10:01 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
justlearning said...
10:02 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
flyer66 said...
10:03 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
sean.jorgensen said...
10:11 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
debmilam said...
10:18 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
coloradoran said...
10:31 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
sallyw said...
10:49 AM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
mormongirl19 said...
12:35 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
mormongirl19 said...
12:41 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
johntvalentine said...
01:29 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
stacy600 said...
01:48 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
pixie said...
04:07 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
me2buc said...
09:59 PM
on Oct 04, 2012
Report Abuse
sleeperhold said...
06:45 AM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
kwg said...
09:29 AM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
imn2k9s said...
09:41 AM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
mormongirl19 said...
01:55 PM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
crystalyo said...
04:45 PM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
crystalyo said...
04:53 PM
on Oct 05, 2012
Report Abuse
vapor said...
08:25 AM
on Oct 06, 2012
Report Abuse
foxylds said...
12:01 AM
on Oct 07, 2012
Report Abuse
imjetta said...
07:45 PM
on Oct 07, 2012
Report Abuse
imjetta said...
07:54 PM
on Oct 07, 2012
Report Abuse
salvar77 said...
09:36 PM
on Oct 07, 2012
Report Abuse
kwg said...
09:10 AM
on Oct 08, 2012
Report Abuse
shatch1 said...
09:53 AM
on Oct 08, 2012
Report Abuse
imjetta said...
10:45 AM
on Oct 08, 2012
Report Abuse
bridget said...
12:07 PM
on Oct 09, 2012
Report Abuse
r2t4 said...
12:09 PM
on Oct 09, 2012
Report Abuse
goofygulch said...
07:52 AM
on Oct 10, 2012
Report Abuse
realtalk723 said...
01:50 PM
on Oct 10, 2012
Report Abuse
bothsides said...
08:34 AM
on Oct 11, 2012
Report Abuse
teachtruthlight said...
10:18 AM
on Oct 11, 2012
Report Abuse
johnrpack said...
09:27 AM
on Oct 13, 2012
Report Abuse
soldiersmother said...
10:07 AM
on Oct 13, 2012
Report Abuse
soldiersmother said...
10:40 AM
on Oct 13, 2012
Report Abuse
lynor said...
05:10 PM
on Oct 14, 2012
Report Abuse
alliegator said...
01:00 PM
on Oct 15, 2012
Report Abuse